36: 1998 Toyota Tacoma SR5 – $11,950
With the high prices of new cars, more consumers are gravitating toward the used car market. The Tacoma is experiencing a rise in used prices and the 1990s models are popular. This was the first generation of the Tacoma and is often credited as the most reliable model (via Trinity Auto).

The 1998 model was extremely reliable, and it did offer decent features for the price. You’ll seldom find a pickup truck line as bulletproof as the Tacoma, but that doesn’t justify the high price tag. There’s no doubt that Tacoma is another victim of the “Toyota” tax.