5. Dodge Caliber
The Dodge Caliber is notorious for its subpar build quality and uninspired driving experience. With cheap interior materials and lackluster performance, the Caliber never gained much traction in the used car market. Its lack of desirability translates directly into low theft rates—thieves simply aren’t interested in a car with so little demand for parts or resale. According to Car and Driver, the Caliber’s forgettable reputation helps keep it safely off the radar of would-be criminals.