1. Pontiac Aztek
The Pontiac Aztek is infamous for its polarizing, awkward design—often topping lists of the “ugliest cars ever made.” Its clunky styling, uninspired performance, and unimpressive interior made it a commercial flop. As a result, there’s little demand for the Aztek or its parts on the used market, making it an unattractive target for thieves. Even though it gained some cult status thanks to TV fame, most criminals steer clear of the Aztek, as confirmed by its consistently low theft rates according to HotCars.