Home Cars Best and Worst Pontiacs Ever Made: The Icons and the Disasters

Cars

Best and Worst Pontiacs Ever Made: The Icons and the Disasters

Cameron Eittreim March 6, 2025

Pontiac built some of the most thrilling cars ever, but not every model was a winner. Some were muscle car legends, while others were forgettable failures. Here’s a deep dive into 20 of the best and worst Pontiacs ever made, showcasing both the triumphs and the disasters that shaped Pontiac’s history.

1969 Pontiac GTO Judge (Best)

Pontiac’s boldest muscle car, the Judge packed a Ram Air III 400 V8 and wild styling. Its iconic “The Judge” decals, hood-mounted tachometer, and aggressive stance made it legendary. This special-edition GTO was built for speed and attitude, cementing its place as one of the ultimate muscle machines.

NEXT >>

1977 Pontiac Firebird Trans Am (Best)

Made famous by Smokey and the Bandit, this black-and-gold beauty was more than just looks. With a 6.6L V8, a screaming chicken hood decal, and T-tops, it became an icon of the late ‘70s. Though emissions regulations hurt performance, its Hollywood fame made it Pontiac’s most recognizable car.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

1967 Pontiac Firebird 400 (Best)

Pontiac’s answer to the Mustang, the Firebird launched with aggressive styling and powerful engines. The 400 model packed a 325-horsepower V8, giving it muscle car credibility. Its sleek design, hood scoops, and performance suspension made it a worthy competitor. It set the stage for decades of Pontiac pony car dominance.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

1964 Pontiac GTO (Best)

The car that started the muscle car craze. Pontiac took a midsize Tempest, stuffed in a 389 V8, and created a street beast. It was raw, powerful, and defined an era. Enthusiasts credit the ‘64 GTO with kicking off the muscle car wars, making it an instant automotive legend.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

1970 Pontiac Firebird Formula 400 (Best)

With its clean, second-gen styling and a 400 cubic-inch V8, the Formula 400 was a serious performer. It wasn’t as flashy as the Trans Am, but it delivered incredible performance. It was a muscle car for those who wanted power without the decals. Today, it’s a sought-after classic.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

1987 Pontiac Grand Prix 2+2 Aerocoupe (Best)

Built to homologate Pontiac’s NASCAR efforts, the Aerocoupe had a sloped rear window for better aerodynamics. Its 305 V8 wasn’t the fastest, but its unique styling made it a collectible. Though production numbers were low, its racing-inspired design and rarity make it one of Pontiac’s more interesting muscle cars.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

1973 Pontiac Grand Am (Best)

Pontiac mixed luxury with performance, creating the Grand Am. It had European-inspired styling, a muscular 455 V8 option, and a sport-tuned suspension. Though emissions restrictions tamed later versions, the original ‘73 model was a fantastic blend of power and refinement. It was one of Pontiac’s most underrated classics.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

1999 Pontiac Firebird Trans Am WS6 (Best)

A fourth-gen Trans Am with the WS6 performance package became a monster. With a ram-air LS1 V8, functional hood scoops, and aggressive styling, it was one of the fastest muscle cars of the late ‘90s. Though Pontiac was nearing its end, this car proved they still had magic left.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

1962 Pontiac Catalina 421 Super Duty (Best)

A full-size car with serious muscle, the Catalina 421 Super Duty was built for drag racing. Its lightweight body and massive V8 dominated the quarter-mile. Though only a few were made, it showcased Pontiac’s racing heritage. This sleeper sedan packed a serious punch, embarrassing smaller, sportier cars.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

2009 Pontiac G8 GXP (Best)

Pontiac’s final performance car was one of its best. Based on the Australian Holden Commodore, the G8 GXP featured a Corvette-derived 6.2L V8 and rear-wheel drive. It was fast, comfortable, and had incredible handling. Sadly, Pontiac’s demise meant this would be its last great sedan, but what a send-off.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

2001 Pontiac Aztek (Worst)

The car that defined “ugly.” While practical, its bizarre styling made it a laughingstock. It later found fame as Walter White’s car in Breaking Bad, but it never overcame its poor sales and bad reputation. Pontiac’s attempt to create a crossover was bold, but ultimately, it was a failure.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

1980 Pontiac Phoenix (Worst)

Pontiac’s compact Phoenix suffered from horrible reliability and cheap build quality. With weak engines, an uninspiring design, and a reputation for breaking down, it was one of Pontiac’s worst efforts. The name might have suggested rebirth, but this car only contributed to Pontiac’s decline in the ‘80s.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

1982 Pontiac J2000 (Worst)

Pontiac’s version of the Chevy Cavalier, the J2000 was plagued with underpowered engines, low-quality materials, and lackluster styling. It failed to deliver performance, and buyers quickly realized it was just a rebadged economy car. It remains one of Pontiac’s most uninspiring models, quickly forgotten by enthusiasts and consumers alike.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

2005 Pontiac Montana SV6 (Worst)

Pontiac tried to make a minivan look sporty. The result was the awkward Montana SV6, which failed to excite families or car enthusiasts. It wasn’t stylish, fast, or practical. Its underwhelming engine, cheap interior, and lack of identity made it a forgettable chapter in Pontiac’s history.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

1988 Pontiac Le Mans (Worst)

A Pontiac in name only, the Le Mans was actually a rebadged South Korean Daewoo. It lacked power, build quality, and reliability. Buyers expected American muscle but got an unreliable compact that fell apart. It was an embarrassment to the Le Mans name, which once symbolized performance.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

1976 Pontiac Astre (Worst)

Pontiac’s version of the infamous Chevy Vega, the Astre inherited all of its flaws. Its aluminum-block engine was unreliable, and rust issues plagued early models. It was underpowered, uninspiring, and lacked the muscle car DNA that Pontiac was known for. It was another forgettable economy car with no personality.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

1993 Pontiac Sunbird (Worst)

The Sunbird was a basic, uninspiring compact that lacked excitement. Its styling was bland, its performance underwhelming, and its interior cheap. Pontiac attempted to inject sportiness, but it never lived up to the brand’s performance reputation. Though affordable, it never stood out and quickly became irrelevant.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

1984 Pontiac Fiero (Early Models) (Worst)

The Fiero had potential, but early models suffered from overheating engines, fire risks, and cheap interiors. Pontiac fixed the issues in later years, but by then, the damage was done. Though the 1988 version was great, the first few years gave the Fiero a terrible reputation.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

1995 Pontiac Grand Prix (W-body Era) (Worst)

Pontiac’s once-great Grand Prix became a dull front-wheel-drive sedan. While earlier models had V8 power, this version was uninspired. Cheap interiors, weak engines, and bland styling made it forgettable. The once-proud nameplate faded into mediocrity, losing its status as a true performance car.

<< Previous

NEXT >>

2008 Pontiac G5 (Worst)

A rebadged Chevy Cobalt that nobody asked for. The G5 was cheap, slow, and uninspired. It was one of Pontiac’s last attempts at an entry-level car before the brand died. With dull styling, weak performance, and a lack of originality, it did nothing to save Pontiac from extinction.

<< Previous

Best and Worst Pontiacs Ever Made: The Icons and the Disasters

1969 Pontiac GTO Judge (Best)

1977 Pontiac Firebird Trans Am (Best)

1967 Pontiac Firebird 400 (Best)

1964 Pontiac GTO (Best)

1970 Pontiac Firebird Formula 400 (Best)

1987 Pontiac Grand Prix 2+2 Aerocoupe (Best)

1973 Pontiac Grand Am (Best)

1999 Pontiac Firebird Trans Am WS6 (Best)

1962 Pontiac Catalina 421 Super Duty (Best)

2009 Pontiac G8 GXP (Best)

2001 Pontiac Aztek (Worst)

1980 Pontiac Phoenix (Worst)

1982 Pontiac J2000 (Worst)

2005 Pontiac Montana SV6 (Worst)

1988 Pontiac Le Mans (Worst)

1976 Pontiac Astre (Worst)

1993 Pontiac Sunbird (Worst)

1984 Pontiac Fiero (Early Models) (Worst)

1995 Pontiac Grand Prix (W-body Era) (Worst)

2008 Pontiac G5 (Worst)

POPULAR