3. Toyota GR86
The Toyota GR86 delivers classic sports car thrills with a modern, fuel-conscious twist. Its lightweight, rear-wheel-drive chassis and crisp steering make every corner a joy, while the efficient 2.4-liter boxer engine returns up to 27 mpg highway. Compared to traditional muscle cars, the GR86 is far less thirsty yet just as engaging. Road & Track lauds its balanced dynamics, showing you can have serious fun without the penalty at the pump.