10 Cars That Made Absolutely No Sense — Until You Drove One

Throughout automotive history, certain vehicles have defied conventional wisdom, often dismissed for their unconventional designs or unexpected features. These cars, initially met with skepticism, have transformed the driving experience, proving that innovation and practicality can coexist. This exploration delves into ten such vehicles that, once experienced firsthand, reveal their unique charm and functionality.

1. Pontiac Aztek

The Pontiac Aztek, introduced in 2001, was initially ridiculed for its unconventional design. However, its practicality and versatility quickly became apparent. Car and Driver noted its unique features, stating, “Not until I drove the Aztek did I realize that the lower portion of the liftgate is glass, a la Honda CRX, so rearward visibility is excellent.” (caranddriver.com)

Designed with active lifestyles in mind, the Aztek offered a range of innovative amenities. Its interior included a removable cooler, a sliding cargo tray, and even a tent attachment, transforming the vehicle into a mobile campsite. (motortrend.com)

Despite its polarizing appearance, the Aztek’s functionality and thoughtful design elements have earned it a dedicated following among those who value utility over aesthetics.

2. Nissan Cube

The Nissan Cube’s distinctive boxy design initially raised eyebrows, but its interior space and handling won over many drivers. Motor Trend highlighted its spaciousness, noting, “The Cube feels surprisingly ginormous… With 42.6 in. of front headroom and 40.2 in. of rear headroom, the Cube offers average-size Americans room beneath the water droplet headliner for all manner of punk hairdos and hipster cowboy hats.” (motortrend.com)

Its compact size and tight turning radius made it ideal for urban environments, while the comfortable, lounge-like interior provided a unique driving experience. The Cube’s blend of practicality and quirky charm endeared it to those willing to embrace its unconventional style. (motortrend.com)

3. Smart Fortwo

The Smart Fortwo’s diminutive size and unconventional design initially led many to question its practicality. However, its compact dimensions made parking in tight urban spaces effortless, and its nimble handling allowed for quick maneuvers through city traffic. Consumer Reports noted, “The tiny city-driving car is back, with better drivability and thoughtful touches.” (consumerreports.org)

Despite its small stature, the Fortwo offered a surprisingly comfortable interior, with a high seating position providing excellent visibility. While its performance was modest, the Fortwo’s unique blend of efficiency and urban agility made it a favorite among city dwellers seeking an eco-friendly and maneuverable vehicle. (consumerreports.org)

4. Subaru Baja

The Subaru Baja, produced from 2002 to 2006, was a unique fusion of car and truck, combining the comfort of a sedan with the utility of a pickup. Its all-wheel-drive system provided excellent traction, making it suitable for various terrains. Autoblog highlighted its versatility, noting, “The Baja was Subaru’s second foray into the truck market here in America, following the classic Brat (which is worth its own article for another time). Whereas the Brat had vestigial seats mounted right in the truck bed, the Baja was a much more refined design that shared most of its mechanical bits with the Legacy and Outback.” (autoblog.com)

Its compact bed was practical for hauling gear, and the rear seats could fold down to extend the cargo area, accommodating longer items. Despite its unconventional appearance, the Baja garnered a loyal following among those who appreciated its practicality and distinctive style. Its all-wheel-drive capability and multipurpose design made it a versatile choice for active individuals seeking a vehicle that could handle both daily commutes and outdoor adventures. (autoblog.com)

5. BMW i3

The BMW i3’s futuristic, boxy design initially raised questions about its practicality. However, its electric acceleration and innovative interior quickly won over skeptics. Top Gear praised its performance, stating, “As with any EV, pottering about town or short inter-urban hopping is generally a joy in an i3.” (topgear.com)

Inside, the i3 featured a minimalist yet high-quality cabin, utilizing sustainable materials like eucalyptus wood and wool fabric. This eco-friendly approach complemented its electric powertrain, offering a unique and engaging driving experience. (honestjohn.co.uk)

6. Honda Element

The Honda Element’s unconventional, boxy design initially raised eyebrows, but its practical features quickly won over active individuals. Edmunds highlighted its versatility, noting, “The Element’s unique rear-hinged rear-seat access doors make side loading a snap, though their design can be a hassle for transporting people — the front doors must first be opened before rear occupants are allowed in or out.” (edmunds.com)

Its spacious cabin, removable rear seats, and easy-to-clean urethane flooring made it ideal for outdoor enthusiasts. The rear seats could be flipped up or removed entirely, allowing for a flat load floor that accommodated bulky items like surfboards or camping gear. The waterproof interior ensured that after a day at the beach or a weekend of camping, cleaning up was a breeze. (edmunds.com)

Despite its quirky appearance, the Element’s thoughtful design and practicality made it a favorite among those seeking a vehicle that could keep up with their active lifestyles.

7. Fiat Multipla

The Fiat Multipla’s unconventional design led to its reputation as one of the “ugliest cars” upon its release. However, its innovative features garnered a dedicated following. Top Gear highlighted its practicality, noting, “The Fiat Multipla dared to be different, to go all Nike on you, and we should applaud it for that, not laugh it out the room.” (topgear.com)

Its unique six-seat configuration, with two rows of three seats, provided ample space for passengers. The interior was designed for flexibility, with seats that could be adjusted or removed to accommodate various cargo needs. Despite its polarizing appearance, the Multipla’s engaging drive and thoughtful design made it a cult favorite among those who valued substance over style. (en.wikipedia.org)

8. Toyota Mirai

The Toyota Mirai’s futuristic design and hydrogen fuel cell technology initially made it appear unconventional. However, its performance and innovative features quickly impressed drivers. Wired noted, “The drive experience is uneventful; almost dull. Again, Toyota is just fine with this. This car performs just like any existing hybrid, being predictable in acceleration and cornering.” (wired.com)

The Mirai’s smooth and silent ride, combined with its zero-emission status, offered a glimpse into the future of automotive technology. Its unique exhaust system even produced water as a byproduct, highlighting its eco-friendly design. (wired.com)

9. Citroën Méhari

The Citroën Méhari’s plastic panels and buggy-like appearance initially made it seem impractical. However, its lightweight design and go-anywhere capability quickly won over enthusiasts. Hemmings notes, “The Mehari took its name from the Dromedary (camelus dromedarius), legendary for their endurance in the face of harsh climates.” (hemmings.com)

Built on the Citroën 2CV platform, the Méhari featured a 602 cc, air-cooled flat-2 engine, delivering 29 horsepower. Despite its modest power, it could reach speeds up to 70 mph. The vehicle’s design allowed for a cargo capacity of 880 pounds, making it versatile for various uses. (hemmings.com)

Its simple construction and durable materials made it easy to maintain and repair, contributing to its enduring popularity among those seeking a fun and practical vehicle. (hemmings.com)

10. Mercedes-Benz G-Class

The Mercedes-Benz G-Class, originally developed as a military off-roader, is renowned for its boxy design and exceptional off-road capabilities. Autocar highlights its enduring appeal, noting that the G-Class has “moved with the times, and moved convincingly,” maintaining its relevance and desirability over decades. (autocar.co.uk)

Despite its utilitarian origins, the G-Class offers a luxurious interior with plush materials and advanced features, blending ruggedness with refinement. Its off-road prowess is unparalleled, equipped with three fully locking differentials, enabling it to tackle challenging terrains with ease. (en.wikipedia.org)

The G-Class’s unique combination of luxury and off-road capability has solidified its status as an iconic vehicle, appealing to those seeking both adventure and comfort.

The Joy of the Unexpected Drive

First impressions often shape our perceptions, but they can be misleading, especially in the automotive world. The “primacy effect” suggests that initial information heavily influences our judgments, potentially leading to misinterpretations. (be-sense.com) By embracing the opportunity to experience unconventional vehicles firsthand, we can challenge these biases and discover unexpected joys. Engaging directly with these cars allows us to appreciate their unique qualities, transforming skepticism into genuine appreciation. This hands-on approach not only broadens our understanding but also enriches our driving experiences.

.article-content-img img { width: 100% }