Cars That Are Cheap to Buy but Expensive to Own

1. BMW 3 Series (E90, E92)

Older BMW 3 Series models, particularly those from the 2006-2013 era, are enticingly affordable on the used market. However, owners often encounter high costs due to European parts, electronic failures, specialized labor, and frequent repairs, especially oil leaks and cooling system issues. Insurance premiums are also higher than average, reflecting the vehicle’s performance capabilities. For a detailed analysis of ownership costs, refer to Consumer Reports.

2. MINI Cooper

MINI Coopers are stylish and affordable to buy used, but their unique engineering leads to inflated maintenance bills. Common issues include transmission failures and cooling system problems, often requiring dealership repairs. Specialists and parts are pricey. Full details can be found on Edmunds.

3. Audi A4

Used Audi A4s are available at budget-friendly prices, but their turbocharged engines and intricate electronics can lead to significant maintenance expenses. Common issues include excessive oil consumption, costly timing belt replacements, and sensor failures, which can quickly add up. Repair costs often surpass those of most mainstream sedans. For a comprehensive analysis of ownership costs, refer to Car and Driver.

4. Land Rover Range Rover

The Range Rover’s rapid depreciation makes it an attractive purchase. However, notorious reliability issues, air suspension failures, and high parts prices render ownership costly. Sophisticated technology often necessitates dealer repairs. Ongoing expenses are so significant that automotive watchdogs routinely caution buyers. For a comprehensive analysis, refer to Jalopnik.

5. Mercedes-Benz C-Class

Used Mercedes-Benz C-Class vehicles are affordable, but their luxury branding and German engineering often lead to high maintenance costs. Common issues include rust, electronic malfunctions, and expensive brake repairs. Insurance premiums are also higher, reflecting the model’s demographics and value. For more information, refer to MotorTrend.

6. Volkswagen Passat

The Volkswagen Passat often sells at discounted prices due to its depreciation, but previous models have experienced costly issues such as turbocharger failures, emissions system problems, and transmission issues. (rerev.com) European parts and specialized service requirements make repairs expensive, offsetting the initial low purchase price. For a detailed breakdown, refer to Kelley Blue Book.

7. Chrysler Sebring/200

While the Chrysler Sebring and its successor, the Chrysler 200, are attractively priced on the used market, they are known for significant reliability issues. Common problems include engine and electrical failures, as well as premature interior wear. These frequent repairs, coupled with poor resale value, can result in total ownership costs that surpass those of competing models. For a detailed analysis of these issues, refer to CarComplaints.

8. Ford Fiesta

Used Ford Fiestas may appear economical, but they are known for dual-clutch transmission issues, engine failures, and low resale value, leading to costly repairs and diminished trade-in value. Certain model years have been subject to lawsuits and recalls. For detailed information, refer to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA).

9. Fiat 500

The subcompact Fiat 500 is attractively priced, but poor reliability, rare parts, and labor-intensive repairs drive up actual ownership costs. Common issues include transmission, electrical, and engine failures, making them expensive to maintain. For more details, refer to AutoWeek.

10. Jaguar X-Type

Jaguar’s reputation for luxury and rapid depreciation is evident in the X-Type. Its initially affordable pricing is offset by persistent electronic issues, all-wheel-drive system faults, and high parts costs. These problems, among others, are detailed in Auto Express’s review. (autoexpress.co.uk)

11. Dodge Avenger

The Dodge Avenger is inexpensive on the used market but is known for frequent transmission failures, suspension wear, and electrical issues. These problems, combined with rapid depreciation, can lead to higher maintenance costs than anticipated. For more information, visit CarComplaints. (carcomplaints.com)

12. Volvo S40

Older Volvo S40s are accessible, but timing belt intervals, suspension troubles, and expensive electronic updates lead to major bills. Safety parts and proprietary tech require Volvo-certified shops for many fixes. See Volvo Forums for owner experiences.

13. Saab 9-3

Attractive pricing lures buyers of the Saab 9-3, but the discontinued make means hard-to-find parts and few qualified mechanics. The turbocharged engines and complex safety systems further inflate repair costs. Owners detail issues on Saabnet.

14. Chevrolet Cruze

The Chevrolet Cruze is plentiful and cheap as a used car, but transmission failures, coolant leaks, and defective electronics result in ongoing maintenance headaches and costs. Recurrent recalls have been reported by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). For more information, visit the NHTSA website. (nhtsa.gov)

15. Smart Fortwo

The Smart Fortwo’s low resale value tempts budget-seekers, but transmission woes and rare components overshadow modest fuel bills. Repairs are challenging due to limited U.S. support. Owner reviews are available at Car and Driver. The Smart Fortwo, a compact city car, has been discontinued in the U.S. market as of 2019. (caranddriver.com) While it offers excellent fuel efficiency, owners have reported transmission issues, including hesitation and jerking during gear shifts. (redriven.com) Additionally, the vehicle’s unique components and limited availability of parts in the U.S. can make repairs both challenging and costly. For more detailed owner experiences and reviews, you can visit Car and Driver’s website.

16. Infiniti QX56

Older Infiniti QX56 models may appear appealing due to their size and features, but they come with significant ownership costs. The large V8 engines consume substantial fuel, averaging around 12 mpg in the city and 17 mpg on the highway, leading to high fuel expenses. (vincheck.info) Additionally, the vehicle’s technology-heavy interiors are prone to malfunctions, and suspension repairs are frequent. Insurance premiums for these large SUVs can also be steep. For more details, see Kelley Blue Book. (rerev.com)

17. Subaru Tribeca

The Subaru Tribeca is affordably priced, but it has been associated with several reliability issues that can lead to high annual ownership costs. Notably, some Tribeca models have experienced excessive oil consumption, with reports indicating that about a quarter of owners have encountered this problem. (consumerreports.org) Additionally, head gasket failures and complex drivetrain repairs are common, further contributing to maintenance expenses. For more detailed information, refer to Consumer Reports’ analysis of the Tribeca. (consumerreports.org)

18. Volkswagen Touareg

The Volkswagen Touareg, a mid-size luxury SUV, depreciates heavily but comes with luxury-level maintenance costs. Its air suspension system, complex electronics, and all-wheel-drive (AWD) system often require frequent and expensive repairs. Additionally, the vehicle’s towing capability and V8 or diesel engine options contribute to higher running costs. For more details, see Edmunds. (yourmechanic.com)

19. Cadillac CTS

While the Cadillac CTS offers a luxury badge at a more accessible price, ownership costs can be substantial. Common issues include timing chain problems, engine electronics failures, and interior component malfunctions. (cartipsdaily.com) Additionally, the vehicle’s requirement for premium-grade gasoline and frequent repair intervals contribute to higher overall expenses. (endurancewarranty.com) For more detailed information, refer to MotorTrend’s analysis of the CTS. (rerev.com)

20. Mazda CX-7

While the Mazda CX-7 is attractively priced on the used market, it has been associated with several reliability issues that can lead to high maintenance costs. The turbocharged engines are known for oil leaks and turbocharger failures, often due to sludge buildup from infrequent oil changes. Timing chain problems can also cause catastrophic engine failures. Long-term reliability is weaker compared to other Mazda models. For more detailed information, refer to CarComplaints.

21. Dodge Journey

The Dodge Journey’s steep depreciation makes it readily available, but persistent electrical, engine, and transmission problems can lead to ongoing repair costs. Models often rank poorly for reliability. Learn more at Consumer Reports. (repairpal.com)

22. Peugeot 308

While used Peugeot 308s are attractively priced, they are known for several reliability issues that can lead to high repair costs. Common problems include:

For more detailed owner experiences and discussions on these issues, refer to AutoExpress.

23. Mitsubishi Eclipse

While the Mitsubishi Eclipse is often available at attractive prices, it is associated with several reliability issues that can lead to significant repair costs. Common problems include:

For more detailed information and owner experiences, refer to CarComplaints. (carcomplaints.com)

24. Hyundai Veracruz

The Hyundai Veracruz offers three-row seating at an attractive price point, but potential buyers should be aware of several factors that can increase long-term ownership costs. Transmission issues are common, with repair or replacement costs ranging from $1,500 to $5,000, depending on the severity of the problem. (transmissiontroublehub.com) Additionally, the Veracruz has experienced rapid depreciation, with a 2010 model losing 28% of its value over three years, resulting in a current resale value of approximately $3,475. (kbb.com) The model has been discontinued, leading to limited availability of parts and potentially higher repair expenses. For more detailed information, refer to Kelley Blue Book’s analysis of the Veracruz. (kbb.com)

25. Acura RL

The Acura RL, while offering luxury features at an accessible price, presents certain maintenance challenges that can increase long-term ownership costs. Common issues include:

For more detailed information on the RL’s reliability and maintenance costs, refer to Edmunds’ analysis. (repairpal.com)

26. Pontiac G6

The Pontiac G6, while abundant on used car lots, is associated with several persistent issues that can lead to significant repair costs. Common problems include:

For more detailed information and owner experiences, refer to CarComplaints. (carcomplaints.com)

27. Mercedes-Benz ML350

The Mercedes-Benz ML350, while available at attractive prices, presents several maintenance challenges that can lead to significant long-term expenses. Common issues include:

Complex Electronics: The ML350’s advanced electronic systems, including the Signal Acquisition Module (SAM), can experience failures, leading to issues with lights, wipers, and power windows. Repair costs can vary widely depending on the extent of the problem. (researchthecar.com)
All-Wheel Drive (AWD) System Issues: The vehicle’s AWD system may develop problems, such as leaks in the power steering rack, leading to loss of steering fluid and potential steering difficulties. Replacing the power steering rack can cost between $1,500 and $3,000. (motorandwheels.com)
Air Suspension Failures: The AIRMATIC air suspension system can experience issues like air spring leaks or compressor failures, resulting in uneven ride heights or a “Suspension Fault” warning light. Repairing or replacing components of the air suspension system can be costly, with individual corner repairs ranging from $1,500 to $2,500, and full system replacements approaching $6,000. (rerev.com)

For more detailed owner experiences and discussions on these issues, refer to the MBWorld forums. (researchthecar.com)

28. Saturn Outlook

The Saturn Outlook, now discontinued, is available at low prices but comes with significant maintenance challenges. Common issues include:

Transmission Failures: Many owners report premature transmission problems, such as slipping gears and complete transmission failure, often requiring costly replacements. For instance, a 2008 Outlook experienced transmission failure at 84,000 miles, with repair costs averaging around $4,300. (carcomplaints.com)
Rare Parts Availability: As the model is no longer in production, sourcing replacement parts can be difficult and expensive, leading to higher repair costs over time. (saturnproblems.com)

For more detailed information and owner experiences, refer to CarComplaints. (carcomplaints.com)

29. Nissan Quest

The Nissan Quest, while offering an affordable initial purchase price, presents several maintenance challenges that can lead to significant long-term expenses. Common issues include:

CVT Transmission Reliability: The Continuously Variable Transmission (CVT) in the Quest has been known to experience failures, leading to costly repairs or replacements. Repair costs can range from $3,000 to $5,000, depending on the extent of the damage and labor rates. (transmissionknowledge.com)
Dealer-Only Repairs: Some repairs, particularly those related to the CVT, may require specialized service centers, often resulting in higher labor costs compared to standard repair shops. (transmissionknowledge.com)
Parts Prices and Labor Costs: Parts for the Quest can be more expensive than average for minivans, and labor hours required for certain repairs may also be above average, contributing to higher overall maintenance costs. (transmissionknowledge.com)

For more detailed information and owner experiences, refer to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) database, which provides a history of complaints and recalls for the 2011 Nissan Quest. (auto-recalls.justia.com)

30. Lincoln MKS

The Lincoln MKS, while often available at lower purchase prices, shares components with higher-end luxury models, leading to elevated repair expenses. Common issues include engine problems, electronic malfunctions, and all-wheel-drive system failures, all contributing to increased maintenance costs over time. For more detailed information, refer to Edmunds’ analysis of the Lincoln MKS. (edmunds.com)