Home Cars Best and Worst: 20 Small Luxury Cars Compared

Cars

Best and Worst: 20 Small Luxury Cars Compared

Jimmy Adell June 9, 2025

Small luxury cars spark lively debates among drivers and enthusiasts alike. These vehicles combine premium features—like high-end interiors, advanced tech, and refined styling—with the agility and efficiency of a compact platform.
Yet, not all models deliver the same blend of performance, comfort, or value. While some shine with thrilling engines and plush cabins, others fall short on ride quality or practicality.
This comparison explores 20 leading small luxury cars, uncovering which truly excel—and which leave drivers wanting more.

NEXT >>

1. Audi A3

The Audi A3 impresses with a refined cabin and precise, responsive handling that makes city and highway driving equally enjoyable.
Its turbocharged engine delivers lively acceleration without sacrificing efficiency. Inside, the A3 feels almost as plush as its larger A4 sibling, thanks to premium materials and a seamless tech interface.
Compared to rivals like the Mercedes A-Class, the A3 offers a quieter, more composed ride, though some may find rear seat space a bit tighter.
Source: Car and Driver

<< Previous

NEXT >>

2. BMW 2 Series Gran Coupe

The BMW 2 Series Gran Coupe stands out for its sporty character and precise steering, offering an engaging experience behind the wheel.
Though its front-wheel-drive platform differs from traditional BMWs, the cabin impresses with premium materials and sophisticated tech features.
When matched against the Mercedes CLA-Class, the 2 Series delivers a firmer ride but rewards keen drivers with superior handling dynamics.
Source: Edmunds

<< Previous

NEXT >>

3. Mercedes-Benz A-Class

Create Me An Image Of(26) — Image source: motor-junkie

The Mercedes-Benz A-Class captures attention with its upscale interior and the highly praised MBUX infotainment system, making every drive both comfortable and connected.
It delivers a smooth, composed ride that feels distinctly premium, even among luxury rivals. However, rear-seat space is somewhat tight, which may deter taller passengers.
Compared to the Audi A3, the A-Class impresses with more advanced tech features but offers slightly less trunk space for luggage or gear.
Source: U.S. News

<< Previous

NEXT >>

4. Lexus IS

The Lexus IS draws buyers with its legendary reliability, plush seating, and a cabin that remains remarkably quiet—even at highway speeds.
Opting for the available V6 engine provides impressive acceleration that outpaces several direct competitors. The IS is particularly well-crafted, with a focus on build quality and materials that feel a class above.
However, it does fall short on rear legroom and trunk space, making it less practical for families or road trips.
Against the Genesis G70, the IS shines in craftsmanship but trails in infotainment technology.
Source: MotorTrend

<< Previous

NEXT >>

5. Genesis G70

The Genesis G70 is a standout underdog in the small luxury car segment, known for its dynamic handling and a well-crafted, upscale cabin.
Drivers often compare its engaging driving experience to the BMW 3 Series, yet the G70 distinguishes itself with a more attractive price point and an industry-leading warranty.
It delivers excellent value without compromising on refinement or performance—making it a compelling choice for those seeking both excitement and affordability.
Source: Kelley Blue Book

<< Previous

NEXT >>

6. Volvo S60

The Volvo S60 stands out with its minimalist Scandinavian design, creating an airy and sophisticated cabin atmosphere.
Renowned for advanced safety technology and exceptionally comfortable seats, the S60 caters to drivers who value peace of mind and long-distance comfort.
Its available plug-in hybrid powertrains further set it apart, delivering efficiency and strong performance. While it comes at a higher price than the Acura TLX, the S60 compensates with a distinctly upscale, premium feel throughout.
Source: Consumer Reports

<< Previous

NEXT >>

7. Acura TLX

The Acura TLX offers an appealing mix of value, reliability, and sporty handling that attracts drivers seeking excitement and dependability.
Its turbocharged engines ensure plenty of power on tap, making daily commutes and spirited drives equally satisfying. However, the infotainment system’s touchpad controls can be unintuitive for some users.
When compared to the Lexus IS, the TLX stands out with a lower price but doesn’t quite match the Lexus in terms of interior luxury and finish.
Source: Edmunds

<< Previous

NEXT >>

8. Cadillac CT4

The Cadillac CT4 brings sharp handling and a uniquely American sense of style to the small luxury car segment.
A punchy turbo-four engine ensures lively acceleration, while the chassis delivers a responsive and engaging drive.
Although the rear seat is tighter than in the BMW 2 Series, the CT4 makes up for it with its bold design and energetic performance.
Source: Car and Driver

<< Previous

NEXT >>

9. Alfa Romeo Giulia

The Alfa Romeo Giulia captivates enthusiasts with its exhilarating handling and unmistakable Italian design flair.
Recent updates have elevated interior quality, making the cabin more inviting and luxurious.
However, reliability concerns continue to shadow the Giulia, which may give some buyers pause.
When it comes to sheer driving excitement, the Giulia easily outshines the Mercedes C-Class, though it lags behind in terms of onboard technology and infotainment sophistication.
Source: Top Gear

<< Previous

NEXT >>

10. Infiniti Q50

The Infiniti Q50 stands out with its potent V6 engine and a cabin that offers generous space for passengers.
Despite these strengths, the Q50’s infotainment system feels outdated, lacking the polish and features of its more modern rivals.
It’s attractively priced compared to the BMW 3 Series, but can’t quite match the BMW’s level of refinement or advanced technology.
Source: U.S. News

<< Previous

NEXT >>

11. BMW 3 Series

The BMW 3 Series is often seen as the benchmark for small luxury cars, excelling in a seamless blend of comfort, performance, and prestige.
Its turbocharged engines provide robust power, while the agile chassis ensures a drive that’s both responsive and rewarding.
Although some drivers may find the ride on the firmer side, the 3 Series offers top-tier technology and an intuitive cabin layout.
It slightly edges out the Genesis G70 in tech features and refinement, though this comes at a higher price point.
Source: Edmunds

<< Previous

NEXT >>

12. Mercedes-Benz CLA-Class

The Mercedes-Benz CLA-Class captures attention with its sleek, coupe-inspired styling and a cabin full of upscale amenities.
Its design-forward approach delivers instant curb appeal, but the trade-off is a smaller back seat and a ride that’s noticeably stiffer than the more comfort-oriented A-Class.
Positioned as a rival to the Audi A3, the CLA-Class offers more visual flair but sacrifices some daily practicality in the process.
Source: Car and Driver

<< Previous

NEXT >>

13. Lexus ES

The Lexus ES is celebrated for its exceptionally smooth ride, luxurious interior, and renowned reliability that stands the test of time.
Though it’s larger than most small luxury cars, its attractive price and robust feature set ensure it remains a strong competitor in this segment.
Compared to the Acura TLX, the ES delivers superior comfort and refinement, though it’s not as sporty or engaging to drive for enthusiasts seeking excitement.
Source: U.S. News

<< Previous

NEXT >>

14. Audi A4

The Audi A4 stands out for its serene, meticulously crafted cabin and a suite of cutting-edge technology that enhances both comfort and connectivity.
Quattro all-wheel drive comes standard on many trims, giving the A4 a distinct advantage in all-weather capability and handling confidence.
Compared to the BMW 3 Series, the A4 delivers a more refined, quieter ride, though it’s just a touch less sporty when pushed on twisty roads.
Source: MotorTrend

<< Previous

NEXT >>

15. Mercedes-Benz C-Class

The Mercedes-Benz C-Class seamlessly blends classic luxury with cutting-edge technology, delivering a plush and inviting interior that feels a step above its peers.
Its refined ride quality and elegant exterior styling make it a top choice for those seeking sophistication and comfort.
Advanced safety features are plentiful, further enhancing its appeal to discerning buyers.
Compared to the A-Class, the C-Class is noticeably more luxurious in both materials and amenities, though this is reflected in its higher price tag.
Source: Edmunds

<< Previous

NEXT >>

16. Acura ILX

The Acura ILX serves as a gateway to the luxury segment, praised for its strong reliability and overall value.
While the ILX includes many premium features for the price, its dated design and technology are clear drawbacks when compared to more modern competitors like the Audi A3.
Still, for buyers seeking an affordable entry point with Acura’s reputation for dependability, the ILX remains a budget-friendly luxury option.
Source: U.S. News

<< Previous

NEXT >>

17. Volvo V60

The Volvo V60 carves its own niche as a luxurious wagon among small luxury cars, offering a rare blend of utility and style.
It boasts a spacious cargo area perfect for active lifestyles, while maintaining Volvo’s reputation for advanced safety technology and elegant Scandinavian design.
Though the V60 comes at a higher price than many sedan rivals, its versatility and premium features make it a standout choice for those who want something different in the luxury segment.
Source: Car and Driver

<< Previous

NEXT >>

18. Genesis G80

The Genesis G80, though a bit larger than typical small luxury cars, stands out with its striking design and high-end materials throughout the cabin.
A smooth, composed ride and an impressive suite of technology position it as a true rival to German sedans, but at a significantly better value.
For buyers seeking luxury, comfort, and modern features without the premium price tag, the G80 is a compelling choice in this competitive segment.
Source: Kelley Blue Book

<< Previous

NEXT >>

19. Jaguar XE

The Jaguar XE stands out for its sharp, responsive steering and unmistakable British charm, making it a favorite among driving enthusiasts.
Its exterior design is both sleek and timeless, while the cabin, though stylish, falls slightly behind German rivals in terms of quality and finish.
The XE is truly a driver’s car at heart, prioritizing engagement and handling.
Potential buyers should be mindful of lingering concerns about reliability and resale value, which can impact long-term ownership.
Source: Top Gear

<< Previous

NEXT >>

20. Cadillac ATS

The Cadillac ATS, though now discontinued, left a mark with its outstanding handling and engaging, sporty drive—traits that made it a genuine contender against the BMW 3 Series.
However, its cramped rear seats and a somewhat basic interior prevented it from reaching the heights of its European rivals. Still, the ATS represented strong value for those prioritizing performance over outright luxury.
As you consider your next small luxury car, remember to weigh driving dynamics, comfort, and features to find the model that fits your lifestyle best.
Source: Edmunds

.article-content-img img { width: 100% }

<< Previous

Best and Worst: 20 Small Luxury Cars Compared

1. Audi A3

2. BMW 2 Series Gran Coupe

3. Mercedes-Benz A-Class

4. Lexus IS

5. Genesis G70

6. Volvo S60

7. Acura TLX

8. Cadillac CT4

9. Alfa Romeo Giulia

10. Infiniti Q50

11. BMW 3 Series

12. Mercedes-Benz CLA-Class

13. Lexus ES

14. Audi A4

15. Mercedes-Benz C-Class

16. Acura ILX

17. Volvo V60

18. Genesis G80

19. Jaguar XE

20. Cadillac ATS

POPULAR